Shearer Forensic Atlas - https://www.toutfait.com/why-the-hatrack-is-andor-is-not-readymade-with-interactive-software-animations-and-videos-for-readers-to-explore. Structured atlas of readymades evidence from 1913–2019. Shearer, R. R. & ASRL, Tout-Fait dossiers (2000–2019) Snow Shovel (1915) Trébuchet (1917) Hatrack Fountain (1917) Bicycle Wheel (1913) Chronology Shearer Methods Visual Matrix Bibliography Generated 2025-11-06 • This page embeds JSON-LD for downstream reuse.

In Advance of the Broken Arm — 1915; 1964

First named readymade: snow shovel purchased 1915, inscribed, and suspended from the studio ceiling. Original lost; 1964 Galleria Schwarz edition.

Year

Event

Medium

Notes

1915

Purchase & inscription

Physical

Hung from wire

1915

Final photograph

2D

Only original record

1916

Letter to Suzanne

Text

Title attested

1964

Schwarz edition

3D replica

8 + 2 AP + 2 HC


Trébuchet (Trap) — 1917; 1964

Reported coatrack left on the floor, later nailed down. Shearer highlights geometry inconsistencies across views.

Hatrack — 1916–18; 1964

Lost original; known via photos and blueprints; Shearer argues no single 3D reconstruction matches all evidence.

Fountain — 1917; 1964

1917 urinal signed “R. Mutt”; original lost. Shearer claims the Stieglitz photo shows compositing and two urinals in 1917.

Bicycle Wheel (with Stool) — 1913; 1916–17; 1964

Prototype readymade (1913). Later version lost. Shearer: blueprint vs edition symmetry issues; decentered axis in modeling.

Readymades Chronology

Shearer Forensic Methods


Visual Evidence 

Illus

Artifact

Year

Medium

Shearer Claim

2A–F

Hatrack

1918–64

6 views

No 3D convergence

12A–D

Bicycle Wheel

1964

Blueprint vs edition

Over-regularization

23A–E

Trébuchet

1941–91

5 views

Hook inconsistencies

34A–H

Fountain

1917–89

10 views

Two urinals / compositing


Bibliography